Collections Blog

Music For Brooklyn

Steamboat Springs was established as a “dry town” by the town founders. A November 21, 1900 Steamboat Pilot article headlined “Ordinance,” enacted prohibition of alcohol sales within town limits and fees for liquor establishments. Every real estate purchase included a deed that contained a no-liquor restriction. As a result of the ordinance, any saloons previously located within Steamboat Springs were required to close or relocate outside of city limits, which created the small neighborhood on the far side of the Yampa River known as Brooklyn.(2)

The Carrie Nation

Gus Durbin was an entrepreneur and saloon owner in Brooklyn. I like him because of the witty name he gave his saloon, The Carrie Nation (Google the name and you’ll understand☺). For his saloon, Gus Durbin purchased a very sophisticated disc music box. The museum now owns Mr. Durbin’s music box.

The Brooklyn saloons were the social hub for many men. It was at the saloon where they heard local and regional news, found work, and I’d like to think, where many men received a little bit of culture by listening to the music box. The museum’s music box includes ten discs that play the songs “Coming Through the Rye,” “She May Have Seen Better Days,” “Treasure Waltz,” and more.

The Regina Music Box

Disc playing music boxes were introduced in Germany in 1885. By 1892 the Regina Music Company opened in New Jersey and quickly become America’s finest and largest music box maker, selling approximately 100,000 units from about 1892 through the mid ‘teens. Regina’s sales grossed about $2 million a year. The cost of a Regina music box was between $12 and $300.

According to Regina factory records, the museum’s music box was shipped from the factory in April of 1895. We do not know if Gus Durbin ordered the music box from the Rahway, NJ factory or if he acquired it later.

Reginas produced a sound that was arguably better than any other music box player on the market, and if you wanted to play to a crowd, which is what this model was designed for, the Regina’s tone and musical arrangement was the best. “It was loud enough for use in a large room without sounding in any way harsh, brash, or unpleasant.”(1)

The Year of 1914 Brought About Change

By the start of World War I the musical box industry was ending. All European makers stopped production by 1914. Regina’s music box production ceased in 1919. The company continued to sell mechanical pianos and in 1924 they started making floor polishers and vacuum cleaners, the brand name is still around today. (3)

1914 also marked the end of the Brooklyn saloons. Changes to state liquor laws and efforts by concerned citizens of Steamboat Springs to clean up the area, forced the closure of the saloons, boarding houses, and brothels in Brooklyn. Who owned the museum’s music box between 1914 and the 1950s isn’t clear. When the museum opened in 1959, the music box was donated by Mrs. McClure Johnson, a local author and artist. Today the music box is being carefully preserved in the Tread of Pioneers Museum’s collection facility.


1. Harry Carmell, late owner of the Regina Music Box Company
2. The Yampa Valley Sin Circuit by Laurel Watson
3. The Musical Box Society International
Steamboat Pilot
Tread of Pioneers Museum records

Blog Update 9/10/15:

The same day I sent this blog to the Director for release, I met a family member of Helena Johnson, the donor of our music box. The coincidence was astonishing to me. Up until my research for this blog, days earlier, I had no knowledge of this remarkable woman. Helena Johnson lived part time in Steamboat Springs and as an author and lover of the outdoors, she helped start the first Boys Camp in Steamboat Springs (which eventually became Lowell Whiteman, now called Steamboat Mountain School). I hope to have further conversations with the family and hopefully learn more details about the music box and its donor.

Posted by Katie Adams at 18:52